Reddit 用户整理 AI 会议桌拒规则
AI 总结
一名 Reddit 用户称,其查看了自 2013 年以来的 NeurIPS、ICML 和 ICLR 投稿通知、作者指南及伦理或 LLM 政策页面,并列出了论文未经评审即遭拒稿的原因。该用户表示,早期规则主要涉及页数限制、匿名和重复投稿等论文问题,而较新的规则包括审稿互惠、审稿人行为、部分 LLM 使用、虚假冲突、合谋及 OpenReview 资料过期等情形。
深度见解
这份汇总将相关桌拒标准集中整理,可能帮助 AI 研究者识别与投稿政策有关的拒稿风险。
| https://preview.redd.it/9fqm4f70731i1.png?width=3200&format=png&auto=webp&s=62bc97590b0eee3ac664a06caa92e66a15e987b6 I went through every NeurIPS, ICML and ICLR call for papers, author guide and ethics/LLM policy page since 2013 (Wayback snapshots near each deadline) and listed every reason a paper can be rejected without review. Until 2023 all the rules were about the paper: page limit, anonymity, dual submission. Now you can get desk rejected for having no reciprocal reviewer, a co-author's negligent reviewing, LLM use (in some cases), false conflicts, collusion, out-of-date OpenReview profile. ICML 2026 had a good writeup on some of this here https://blog.icml.cc/2026/03/18/on-violations-of-llm-review-policies/ Do you think we should have more of these rules? Reform or revolution? submitted by /u/martincsweiss [link] [comments] |