Reddit user catalogs AI conference desk-rejection rules
AI summary
A Reddit user says they reviewed NeurIPS, ICML and ICLR calls for papers, author guides and ethics or LLM policy pages dating back to 2013, then listed reasons papers can be rejected without review. The user says earlier rules focused on paper issues such as page limits, anonymity and dual submissions, while newer rules include reviewer reciprocity, reviewer conduct, some LLM use, false conflicts, collusion and outdated OpenReview profiles.
In-depth insight
By organizing the stated desk-rejection criteria in one place, the catalog may help AI researchers identify policy-related submission risks.
| https://preview.redd.it/9fqm4f70731i1.png?width=3200&format=png&auto=webp&s=62bc97590b0eee3ac664a06caa92e66a15e987b6 I went through every NeurIPS, ICML and ICLR call for papers, author guide and ethics/LLM policy page since 2013 (Wayback snapshots near each deadline) and listed every reason a paper can be rejected without review. Until 2023 all the rules were about the paper: page limit, anonymity, dual submission. Now you can get desk rejected for having no reciprocal reviewer, a co-author's negligent reviewing, LLM use (in some cases), false conflicts, collusion, out-of-date OpenReview profile. ICML 2026 had a good writeup on some of this here https://blog.icml.cc/2026/03/18/on-violations-of-llm-review-policies/ Do you think we should have more of these rules? Reform or revolution? submitted by /u/martincsweiss [link] [comments] |