Eric Betzig Warns AlphaFold Alone Cannot Solve Drug Discovery
Nobel laureate Eric Betzig argued in a podcast interview that using AlphaFold protein structures alone for drug discovery is unlikely to succeed, because cells are dynamic, crowded, multiscale systems. He proposed combining live-cell 4D/5D imaging, self-supervised vision Transformers and zebrafish models to study drug effects from molecules to whole organs, while also criticizing academic incentives built around papers, grants and peer review.
The critique highlights the gap between static protein-structure prediction and the dynamic, multiscale biology required for drug development.
一位诺贝尔化学奖得主最近公开表示,生物学教科书里面几乎所有的东西都是幻觉。在同一档播客里,他还表示如果明天把学术界砍掉 95%,这个世界不会有任何感觉。他还给出这样一个判断,用 AlphaFold 开发新药一定会失败,称这些药企“正在无谓地烧钱(burning money for nothing)”。
说出这些话的人是 Eric Betzig,他是 2014 年诺贝尔化学奖得主,在美国加州大学伯克利分校担任教授。他在此次访谈里多次爆粗口,用词非常冲。但是这背后可能是一套完整的判断,涉及到了科研体制、AI 制药和活细胞成像三个层面。他希望谈的是当科学被论文、基金和奖项驱动时,到底科学还剩下多少探索的空间。
#Eric Betzig#AlphaFold#Howard Hughes Medical Institute#SpaceX