Hands-on: Meta Muse vs ChatGPT Dot across Chinese apps
A hands-on comparison by 字母AI, republished by 钛媒体 and 36氪, tested Meta's Muse against Dot inside ChatGPT on tasks including adding Apple Calendar events, syncing health data, cleaning a 126 mailbox, posting to social media, finding a restaurant on Dianping, picking shoes on JD and building a shareable five-person travel expense ledger. Muse completed the calendar and health tasks from an iPhone after a single authorization prompt and batch-deleted 191 matching emails; Dot could not operate the iPhone calendar directly and needed a connected Mac, but it spotted a timestamp inconsistency in an email and drafted a reply, and it delivered a ledger that recalculated correctly and synced edits made by a friend, while Muse's ledger reverted on refresh and could not sync. The review cites a Similarweb estimate of about 2.18 million daily active users for Muse on October 5, and notes both agents still stumble on Chinese sites that require logins and CAPTCHAs; the reviewer also acknowledges that in some tasks the two ran in different environments, with Dot using the user's Mac and Muse a cloud computer.
The tests show that direct access to phone system permissions, or a smooth cloud-computer login flow, largely determines whether a personal agent can finish everyday tasks.
(本文作者为 字母AI,钛媒体经授权发布)
文 | 字母AI
上线一个多月,Muse目前还没有“昙花一现”。根据Similarweb公布的估算数据,它在10月5日的日活跃用户已达到约218万。
我最初只是想简单试用,如今遇到添加日程、整理邮件这些琐事,已经习惯先找它帮忙。
另一边,Dot也已在手机端开放,在ChatGPT应用中有了一级入口。同样是个人Agent,Muse和Dot用起来到底有什么区别?让这些“洋Agent”处理网易邮箱邮件、在国内电商网站挑选商品,会发生什么?
带着这些问题,我把几件真实的日常任务分别交给了它们,做了一番对比实测。
Some source content is omitted. Continue reading on the original site.
#Meta#Muse#OpenAI#ChatGPT#Dot#Apple Calendar#Threads#Similarweb#京东#大众点评