OpenAI Announces Three AI-Produced Science Results and New Release Plan
OpenAI announced three claimed results produced by its internal models: a proof of the local smoothing conjecture in harmonic analysis, a refutation of the Exponential Time Hypothesis (ETH) in complexity theory, and a physics result concerning quantum chromodynamics and the Standard Model. The company described the manuscripts as raw research data requiring outside scrutiny. Following advice from external experts acting as “shepherds,” OpenAI said it would release the math output openly, make the computer-science output public while forming an external collaborator group, and leave the physics release to outside experts. The math and computer-science proofs were also translated into Lean, according to OpenAI. Researchers contacted by The Verge welcomed the smaller set of results but questioned restricting initial access to OpenAI-selected experts. Brendan Hassett said the math conclusion appeared well supported but that he had not verified its Lean formalization.
The announcement concerns possible AI-generated advances in major research fields, but the manuscripts remain unverified research claims rather than established discoveries. OpenAI’s field-specific release plan also raises a substantive access dispute: researchers interviewed for The Verge argued that public announcements should allow anyone to examine the underlying work. The ETH result could also require cryptographers to reassess other assumptions underlying encryption methods, although one report said it would not endanger current encryption systems.
We are announcing three new discoveries in mathematics, computer science, and physics about harmonic analysis, complexity theory, and quantum field theory.
Our release process continues to evolve in response to feedback from the associated academic communities. In our view, these manuscripts are best understood as a form of raw research data. To convert this raw research data into scientific understanding, in this release we are experimenting with a new approach. We reached out to external experts and asked them to act as shepherds, organizing groups to understand the new results. They advised three different release strategies:
- For the math result, release the AI output, leaving researchers free to organize their own efforts to explain the result.
- For the computer science result, form an external group of collaborators to explain the result, while making the AI output publicly available for anyone to examine and build on.
- For the physics result, form an external group of collaborators and defer to them on the release of materials.
We do not yet know which of these three approaches will be most useful, and we welcome feedback on what works and what we can improve.