Reddit帖子质疑CVPR每位作者25篇投稿上限
一则Reddit帖子引用CVPR 2027指南称,每位作者最多提交25篇论文,超出上限的投稿将被程序主席直接拒稿。发帖者表示,只要研究想法可靠、实验合理,其并不反对AI辅助研究或写作,但主张将第一作者投稿数限制在2至3篇,以促使作者更重视展示、写作和研究想法。发帖者预测,降低上限将减轻审稿负担,并称大量投稿可能利用粗心或缺乏经验的审稿人。现有报告未独立核验所引指南,关于审稿行为和审稿负担的说法也只是发帖者的意见或预测。
该帖将CVPR的一项具体投稿规则与AI辅助研究、论文质量和审稿负担等疑问联系起来,但现有材料未核验指南,帖中提出的潜在效果也未获证明。
As per the the 2027 CVPR guidelines:
"Maximum number of submissions (continuing from CVPR 2026): Each author may submit at most 25 papers. If an author enrolls more than 25 papers, the Program Chairs (PCs) will desk-reject the submissions that exceed this limit (see the Desk Rejection Policy in Section 2)."
AI Slop Researcher: "Cool let me throw 25 darts (slop papers), surely one will get a batch of careless/inexperienced reviewers that will borderline accept one of these papers"
They collect their CVPR stamp, and go on about their career.
I just do not understand if a 25 cap is being tone deaf to the current AI driven research climate or what?
I am actually not against AI-assisted paper research/writing as long as the idea is sound and experiments are plausible, but 25 is absurd. If they limited the number of first author submissions to 2-3:
- Researchers are incentivized and know the importance of being first author.
- Even if you AI generate your paper, if you only get 2-3 shot/submissions at a A* conference versus 25, you'd care a bit more about your presentation quality/idea soundness/writing. (In theory lol)
- Reviewer load drops massively, more time can be dedicated to an overall lower submission count.
Are the heads not aware of the slugfest happening in **certain** countries and institutions to have A* venue stamps for career advancement/compensation packages, and that they don't give a damn about ethics?
submitted by /u/mofoss [link] [comments]