Google 的 Gemini 单次提示足迹估算遭质疑
Google 在 2025 年 8 月的技术论文中估算,Gemini Apps 文本提示的中位数为消耗 0.24 Wh 能量、排放 0.03 克二氧化碳当量并使用 0.26 毫升水。TechRadar 称,该方法涵盖 AI 加速器、主机 CPU、内存、待机容量和数据中心开销,但研究者质疑其用水核算及基于市场的排放口径。Google 还称中位提示的能耗和碳足迹在 12 个月内分别下降 33 倍和 44 倍,但 TechRadar 指出这些结果取决于计算是否成立。
报道凸显大规模使用下单次提示环境估算的局限:Gemini Apps 据报于 2026 年 8 月月活突破 10 亿,而 Google 2025 年总用水量增长 34% 至 109 亿加仑。
Asking Gemini to rewrite your email costs about five drops of water. At least, that's what Google says.
In an August 2025 technical paper, the company estimated that a median Gemini Apps text prompt uses 0.24 Wh of energy, emits 0.03 grams of CO2 equivalent and consumes 0.26 mL of water.
Google compared the energy use to watching TV for less than nine seconds. It also claimed that over a 12-month period, the energy and carbon footprint of a median prompt fell by 33x and 44x respectively. Those are big efficiency gains, assuming the math holds up.
A technically correct figure
Credit where it's due, Google's method counts more than most. Alongside the AI chips themselves, it includes host CPUs and memory, idle machines kept on standby, plus data center overhead like cooling. If you count only active TPUs and GPUs, the numbers drop to 0.10 Wh and 0.12 mL, which Google itself calls an underestimate.
By Google's own breakdown, the AI accelerators account for 58% of the energy behind each prompt. Host CPUs and memory take another 24%, with spare capacity and data center overhead making up the remaining 18%.
#Google#Gemini Apps#GPT-3#Meta#Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory#Shaolei Ren#Alex de Vries-Gao