Create

Sign in to ReadmeX

or

How we handle your data: Privacy Policy

ReadmeX

Your AI reading companion

What would you like to catch up on?

Pick a briefing, or ask your own question.

Your community and people briefings stay personal to you.

Story

Commentary: the PHP flaw is hard to exploit, and LLM-written PoCs don't work

AI summary

A Hacker News post argues that while the recently disclosed PHP memory bug is real and significant, it is far harder to exploit than Log4Shell, Heartbleed or the Rails YAML flaw, despite a PHP core team member reportedly calling it cataclysmic. The author says thousands of "PoC" exploits on GitHub do not work against a vanilla PHP instance, and that many chains depend on a pre-existing local-file-inclusion weakness. The post attributes the confusion to people relying on LLMs such as Claude and GPT to judge exploitability, saying the models produce confident transcripts of exploits that do not actually work.

In-depth insight

The post claims LLM-assisted exploit development spread thousands of non-working proofs of concept and shaped how the security community read the PHP disclosure.

I know, I know. It's all you're hearing about. That, and the number 4.

Don't get me wrong, there's clearly a bug here and it really does matter. But this is not easy to exploit. It is certainly nowhere near as eay as Log4Shell/Heartbleed/RoRYaml etc.

Justify yourself, you lunatic!

I don't think this PHP vulnerability is that exploitable. I think that 5 years ago people would've understood this, but now people are being deluded by their LLMs telling them they have an exploit when they don't.

If you take a look at github right now, there are thousands, literally thousands, of "PoC" exploits for this vulnerability. One thing you'll notice about all of them though, is that they do not work against a vanilla PHP instance.

Go ahead, stand up a php server you think is vulnerable in Docker and then run the PoC yourself. Don't get your LLM to do it. No. Run the script, yourself. The exploits don't work.

#PHP#GitHub#Claude#GPT#Log4Shell

Original · 4 min readRead the original
Group chat

No comments yet. Start the conversation.