研究者称当前AI没有意识
Anil Seth、Ned Block和Giulio Tononi在《自然》发表评论,认为当前AI系统缺乏主观体验,沿硅基计算路线产生意识的可能性也极低。他们从智能与意识的区别、计算功能主义以及整合信息论出发,反对“执行正确计算就足以产生意识”的观点。其结论比Butlin报告更坚定,后者认为现有系统不太可能是意识候选者,但对未来系统仍持开放态度。
这篇评论以科学观点直接回应AI可能已有意识的说法,并涉及AI福利、AI权利以及监管资源应如何分配的问题。
The brain-as-computer metaphor shaped modern AI but may be misleading the consciousness debate
Nov 8, 2026

Three leading consciousness researchers argue today's AI isn't conscious and probably can't be on silicon hardware. They reject the idea that running the right computations is enough for consciousness, challenging a central assumption in the debate.
Anil Seth, Ned Block, and Giulio Tononi have spent decades researching consciousness from the perspectives of experimental neuroscience, theoretical neurobiology, and philosophy of mind. Their commentary responds to voices like biologist Richard Dawkins and AI pioneer Geoffrey Hinton, who consider AI systems possibly already conscious.
#Anil Seth#Ned Block#Giulio Tononi#Nature#Anthropic#Claude#Patrick Butlin#Robert Long#Richard Dawkins#Geoffrey Hinton#AlphaFold#GPT-4