Researchers Argue Current AI Lacks Consciousness
In a Nature commentary, Anil Seth, Ned Block, and Giulio Tononi argue that current AI systems lack subjective experience and are unlikely to become conscious through silicon-based architectures. Drawing on intelligence research, computational functionalism, and Integrated Information Theory, they reject the assumption that performing the right computations is sufficient for consciousness. Their conclusion is firmer than the Butlin report, which found current systems unlikely consciousness candidates but left the possibility of future systems open.
The commentary adds a prominent scientific challenge to claims that AI may already be conscious, while raising questions about AI welfare, rights, and the allocation of regulatory attention.
The brain-as-computer metaphor shaped modern AI but may be misleading the consciousness debate
Nov 8, 2026

Three leading consciousness researchers argue today's AI isn't conscious and probably can't be on silicon hardware. They reject the idea that running the right computations is enough for consciousness, challenging a central assumption in the debate.
Anil Seth, Ned Block, and Giulio Tononi have spent decades researching consciousness from the perspectives of experimental neuroscience, theoretical neurobiology, and philosophy of mind. Their commentary responds to voices like biologist Richard Dawkins and AI pioneer Geoffrey Hinton, who consider AI systems possibly already conscious.
#Anil Seth#Ned Block#Giulio Tononi#Nature#Anthropic#Claude#Patrick Butlin#Robert Long#Richard Dawkins#Geoffrey Hinton#AlphaFold#GPT-4