资深法官呼吁讨论AI辅助审判
在WIRED的采访中,Geoffrey Vos表示,各国法院可考虑使用AI协助处理部分民事争议,以更快、更低成本地解决纠纷。他认为,人身伤害索赔和低价值的专业疏忽案件可由AI进行裁决,而复杂的商业纠纷及敏感的家庭案件仍可能需要人类法官。Vos使用Microsoft Copilot查找文件、梳理大量材料并核查信息,但不用它撰写判决。他表示,公众要接受算法裁决,需要同意个案中的相关程序,或由社会通过立法予以认可。
Vos的评论呈现了AI日益普及后法院面临的实际与伦理问题。他强调,推广算法裁决需要公众同意或立法支持,并应形成广泛共识,以维护人们对司法体系的信任;模型的决策过程是否可理解,以及人类法官应扮演什么角色,也是这场讨论的核心。
In a few days, judge Geoffrey Vos will retire as Master of the Rolls, the most senior position in England’s civil justice system. As one of his final acts, he’s trying to stoke a debate about whether—and how—judges should be using artificial intelligence.
Under the latest guidance, judges in England are advised to confine their use of AI to administrative tasks, and Vos tells WIRED he uses Microsoft Copilot all the time to locate far-flung documents and summarize large bodies of text. But recently, he visited a court in Shenzhen, China, where civil disputes are already being decided by judges with heavy assistance from AI. Impressed by what he saw, Vos believes that courts across the globe should consider following.
That road is littered with pitfalls. Multiple lawyers have been caught citing case law hallucinated by AI, and in a first for the UK, somebody recently lost their license to practice in part because they misused the technology. Meanwhile, with chatbots as their legal counsel, litigants are flooding the courts with an unprecedented number of claims, some of them bogus.