Senior Judge Calls for Debate on AI-Assisted Adjudication
In a WIRED interview, Geoffrey Vos said courts worldwide should consider using AI to help resolve some civil disputes more quickly and at lower cost. He suggested that personal injury claims and low-value professional negligence cases could be adjudicated with AI, while complex commercial disputes and sensitive family cases may still require human judges. Vos uses Microsoft Copilot to find documents, navigate large amounts of material and check information, but does not use it to write judgments. He said public acceptance of algorithmic decision-making would require consent to the process in a particular case or legislation.
Vos's comments frame the practical and ethical questions courts face as AI becomes more widely used. He emphasized the need for public consent or legislation, broad consensus and confidence in the justice system, while identifying explainability and the role of human judges as central issues in the debate.
In a few days, judge Geoffrey Vos will retire as Master of the Rolls, the most senior position in England’s civil justice system. As one of his final acts, he’s trying to stoke a debate about whether—and how—judges should be using artificial intelligence.
Under the latest guidance, judges in England are advised to confine their use of AI to administrative tasks, and Vos tells WIRED he uses Microsoft Copilot all the time to locate far-flung documents and summarize large bodies of text. But recently, he visited a court in Shenzhen, China, where civil disputes are already being decided by judges with heavy assistance from AI. Impressed by what he saw, Vos believes that courts across the globe should consider following.
That road is littered with pitfalls. Multiple lawyers have been caught citing case law hallucinated by AI, and in a first for the UK, somebody recently lost their license to practice in part because they misused the technology. Meanwhile, with chatbots as their legal counsel, litigants are flooding the courts with an unprecedented number of claims, some of them bogus.