METR质疑Anthropic失配风险评估
METR发布了对Anthropic 2026年8月《风险报告》中“高风险场景下的失配”一节的外部审查。METR的最终判断是,报告所覆盖模型的灾难性失配风险较低,但这主要源于模型能力有限,而非安全护栏或对齐训练已经充分。METR称该报告不足以令人有把握地排除失配风险,认为其隐蔽能力基准不能充分代表模型规避内部监控的能力,并建议公开四类被删减的信息。
METR的审查直接质疑Anthropic低风险结论的证据基础,并指出其对齐评估和内部监控能否识别有害行为仍存在关键疑问。
Scope and access: this review was written based solely on Anthropic’s internal Risk Report from August 2026 and is relatively lightweight. The authors of this review were engaged prior to the “An update on independent evaluators” announcement and did not have the level of access to information described in that post. We expect future engagements to be governed by different terms.
Redaction summary statement: Anthropic had the right to veto publication of this review and to redact any part of it. No redactions were made to our review and we did not change any of our conclusions during the publication review process. METR made minor changes to our review in response to feedback from Anthropic, but these changes were limited to minor wording and clarification, as well as improving the methodology of an experiment we ran.
Executive summary
METR conducted an external review of the “Misalignment in high-stakes settings” section of Anthropic’s Risk Report: August 2026. Anthropic’s report concludes that, as of July 15, 2026, “the risk of catastrophic harm caused by misalignment of [their] models is low.”