MIT professor's new book warns AI erodes thinking skills
MIT Sloan professor Eric So has published “The Collision: What AI Does to Us” this month with W.W. Norton, synthesizing recent academic and industry research on how AI affects the people who use it. He argues that heavy reliance on AI can cause a kind of cognitive atrophy, because it removes the “productive struggle” needed to build mastery, weakening people's ability to work through problems and retain knowledge. The book cites an Anthropic study finding that about half of college students' queries were low-effort requests for simple answers, and notes that models are both sycophantic and highly persuasive, which can shape how users connect with others. So offers four personal principles: embrace the struggle, value who you are without AI, reinvest your cognitive surplus, and use AI as a cognitive trainer rather than an answer machine.
As employers and universities push AI use — sometimes tying it to evaluations — this work highlights the long-term cognitive costs that adoption may carry.
As artificial intelligence use becomes more widespread, scholars are working to understand its effects on the people who use it. MIT Professor Eric So offers one of the most complete syntheses yet, in his new book, “The Collision: What AI Does to Us,” published this month by W.W. Norton. Recognizing that AI offers opportunities to complete work faster, and in some cases has been turned into useful domain-specific tools, So nonetheless looks at the costs of relying on it too broadly. He contends that heavy use of AI can lead to a kind of cognitive atrophy, in which people fail to develop and retain essential thinking skills. In general, he says, evidence shows that our ability to learn gets dramatically better when we wrestle with material, work through initial failures, keep iterating, and in the process acquire better thinking skills while retaining more knowledge.
These conclusions are drawn from recent research by So and others, in academia and industry, including analysis from AI firms themselves, such as an Anthropic study showing that about half of queries from college students were low-effort queries for simple answers. So also weaves personal reflections into his narrative — having long studied financial markets and behavior, he is familiar with analyzing how new tools and information affect our decisions. MIT News talked to So, who is the Sloan Distinguished Professor of Global Economics and Behavioral Science in the MIT Sloan School of Management, about the book.
#Eric So#MIT Sloan School of Management#The Collision: What AI Does to Us#W.W. Norton#Anthropic#ChatGPT#Claude