OpenAI's mass release of machine-generated math proofs draws mathematician backlash
A commentary piece says OpenAI released 722 machine-generated math manuscripts in October, organized into 372 result groups, some touching the frontiers of modern mathematics, after claiming in September that an internal model solved the Navier-Stokes equation in 88 hours. It says 25 mathematicians including Terence Tao had warned of risks in a statement titled "Severe Misalignment of AI in Mathematics," and that researchers such as theoretical computer scientist Dana Moshkovitz found the proofs unreadable and lacking peer review — a condition Tao called "proof indigestion." The article also claims Anthropic's Claude found a counterexample to the Jacobian conjecture in algebraic geometry and raised lower bounds on the proportion of Riemann zeta zeros, framing OpenAI's move as "performance marketing" amid IPO and revenue pressure. These claims come from this commentary and were not independently verified.
If accurate, it shows AI-generated proofs at scale straining peer review and verification, with vendor competition potentially outpacing the field's ability to absorb results.
历史无数次向我们证明:搞科研的永远玩不过商人和政客。
1945年,原子弹之父奥本海默去白宫见杜鲁门,当面说出这句话「我觉得我的双手沾满鲜血」。杜鲁门对他的垂头丧气很反感,私下和助手吐槽:「血在我手上,让我来操心就好」。并吩咐属下以后不要把这个爱哭的科学家带进办公室。
2026年,当陶哲轩联合其他24位全球顶尖数学家呼吁抵制AI对数学的侵害时,不知是否有着类似的被欺骗之感。因为在两年以前,他还曾非常乐观地畅想「工业化数学」的未来,并公开表示自己联手ChatGPT攻克了 MathOverflow难题,极大地节省了繁琐的计算时间。到了2026年,陶哲轩更是将AI直接融入了日常核心工作流。
蜜月期结束在2026年秋天,OpenAI利用内部模型宣称在88小时内解决了「千禧难题」中的纳斯·斯托克方程,9月,陶哲轩等25名数学家发布《人工智能在数学中的严重错位》,提前预警AI介入基础数学研究的巨大风险。