创建

登录 ReadmeX

或

了解我们如何处理你的信息: 隐私政策

ReadmeX

陪你读懂 AI 动态

今天,想先了解什么?

选一份动态总结,或直接聊聊你的问题。

社区和关注动态总结只属于你自己。

资讯

学者失去ChatGPT后转向Claude

AI 总结

一名 Reddit 用户称其 ChatGPT 账号因违反条款而失去访问权限,随后将几乎全部日常活动转向 Claude。该用户表示 Claude Code 很有帮助,但使用 Claude 修改写作时需要更明确的指令,面对开放式问题时也更倾向于总结各种考量而非直接给出立场。

深度见解

这则用户经历比较了 Claude 与 ChatGPT 在写作、客观问题、应用集成和使用额度方面的使用体验,但属于未经核实的个人叙述,并非独立测试。

I’m an academic who lost access to ChatGPT last week due to a terms violation. Because it seems like I'll never get my account back, I’ve shifted almost all of my daily activity to Claude, which I’ve been using on-and-off for the past couple of months along with ChatGPT. Claude Code has especially been helpful, but maybe because I'm not a coder, I’ve relied on ChatGPT for almost everything else (checking and replying to emails, drafting and revising writing, research, life-related searches, comparing consumer items, legal matters, etc).

The transition overall has been quite difficult, especially in these aspects, and I was wondering if you had any advice on how I can optimise it.

  • ChatGPT was the king for revising writing. I could paste in a draft of an email or an article I’m writing with a vague command like ‘improve’ or ‘revise’ and it seemed to know almost exactly what I’m looking for from it without changing too much. With Claude, I have to spell this out every time, and it still sometimes drifts into ‘improving’ things I didn’t ask about. I’ve saved the rules in my preferences, and it helps, but it isn’t the same as being understood like ChatGPT understood my intentions.
  • Claude seems to do well with questions (medical, legal) that have an objective answer, but struggle with those that require interpretive, interesting discussion-based answers (politics, film analysis, philosophy). ChatGPT would commit to an interpreation or an argument, and tell me what would change its mind. Claude tends to give a careful summary of the considerations and stop. It’s good for facts, but for anything with no definitive answer, Claude’s answers are very underwhelming and frankly quite boring to read, even after I tell it what I’m looking for.
  • The most difficult part has been losing the full integration of email, calendar, files and past conversations, all feeding one assistant, which meant I could ask a vague question and it knew what I meant. I’m rebuilding that here with connectors and Projects, but it’s piecemeal.

#ChatGPT#Claude#Claude Code#OpenAI#Anthropic

原文约 2 分钟读完阅读原文
群聊

还没有评论,来说说你的看法。