Chaptr停用被员工认为不可靠的NOA助手
《连线》报道,麦克米伦出版社于2024年1月高调介绍由Chaptr开发的办公聊天机器人NOA,现场布置了气球、横幅和写着“NOA IS HERE”的甜甜圈。员工被鼓励用NOA撰写邮件和文案、开展营销调研及生成创意,而培训中则警告该工具可能产生幻觉,需要人工核查。多名员工认为NOA无用且不可靠,一人说没人使用它。2025年10月,麦克米伦员工通过全公司邮件得知Chaptr将停用该工具。
NOA受到大力推广但使用有限,加之员工的可靠性担忧和人工核查要求,这一案例具体呈现了麦克米伦在引入办公AI助手时面临的实际挑战。
As staff at the Lower Manhattan headquarters of Macmillan Publishers headed into work one morning in January 2024, they filed past something strange on the walls—flyers welcoming a new member of the team named “NOA.” The cafeteria was festooned with purple balloons and banners, according to several workers present, and with NOA’s name in light-up marquee letters. A plate full of doughnuts spelled out “NOA IS HERE.”
NOA was an acronym for No Ordinary Assistant, which many of Macmillan’s human assistants found “offensive,” multiple employees tell WIRED. In an email to staff, NOA was introduced as an AI chatbot developed by the German software company Chaptr, which is “backed” by Holtzbrinck, Macmillan’s parent company.
The email also assured employees NOA was “a safe environment where you can input proprietary information without the risk of sharing that data with any third party.” Ostensibly, this means NOA was a closed-loop enterprise tool that did not retain or share data for model training.
Macmillan staffers say they were warned during training sessions that NOA could hallucinate and would always need to be fact-checked by humans. Still, employees say, they were encouraged to use NOA for composing emails, drafting copy, doing marketing research, and generating ideas. Multiple staffers say they were told to “only” paste a “percentage” of authors’ manuscripts into NOA. Employees could also adjust NOA’s speaking tone, with options including “lighthearted,” “spartan,” pessimistic,” “sarcastic,” and “regretful.”