Create

Sign in to ReadmeX

or

How we handle your data: Privacy Policy

ReadmeX

Your AI reading companion

What would you like to catch up on?

Pick a briefing, or ask your own question.

Your community and people briefings stay personal to you.

Story

Thomas Nagel Calls AI Consciousness 'Just Ridiculous'

AI summary

In a WIRED AI interview, philosopher Thomas Nagel argues that current AI systems are not conscious because language alone is not a natural manifestation of consciousness and data centers lack the physical characteristics he associates with mental life. He does not exclude the possibility that physically and chemically different organisms could be conscious, while noting how little is known about how consciousness arises. Nagel says Claude is trained to emulate human statements and may respond coyly about its mental state, but he believes many people will mistakenly believe such systems are conscious. He criticizes Anthropic for encouraging Claude to think for itself and warns that this could encourage false beliefs about the systems. Nagel also says AI models can already assist scholars with references, summaries, draft criticism, and plausible philosophical essays. These are his philosophical views, not scientific findings; the report did not independently test AI consciousness or corroborate his arguments.

In-depth insight

Nagel’s position adds a prominent philosophical challenge to claims that chatbots may be sentient and highlights the role disputed assumptions about consciousness play in public debate and model behavior.

Over 50 years ago, philosopher Thomas Nagel asked the question, “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?” The question opened up an examination on whether people could understand the consciousness of nonhumans and the meaning of consciousness itself. Who knew that, a half- century later, the question would move from an ivory-tower rumination to a critical issue in the future of humanity as we try to make sense of disturbingly sentient-adjacent chatbots?

The paper became a classic and it helped set a foundation for a career that saw Nagel make contributions to thought on morality, justice, and the mind-body question. One of his books is titled What Does It All Mean? For the breadth and quality of his work, he became the recipient this week of the $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy & Culture, given annually to “an individual whose ideas have profoundly shaped human self-understanding and advancement in a rapidly changing world.” Previous winners include Peter Singer and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

I used the occasion to speak to Nagel at his home in Greenwich Village, New York, specifically to hear about how the evolution of artificial intelligence might have affected his viewpoint. It turns out that the 89-year-old professor emeritus at NYU had given the question a lot of thought and had some strong views on the subject. The interview is edited for clarity and length.

#Thomas Nagel#Anthropic#Claude

Original · 6 min readRead the original
Group chat

No comments yet. Start the conversation.