创建

登录 ReadmeX

或

了解我们如何处理你的信息: 隐私政策

ReadmeX

陪你读懂 AI 动态

今天,想先了解什么?

选一份动态总结,或直接聊聊你的问题。

社区和关注动态总结只属于你自己。

资讯

ICLR 2027作者称一份审稿意见疑似写错论文

AI 总结

一名ICLR 2027投稿作者称,三位审稿人中的一位描述了无关的研究问题、方法和实验,却仍给出拒稿。另有一位审稿人则被作者批评未仔细阅读论文,忽略了研究现有方法局限性的明确目标;作者正考虑联系Area Chair,报道未提及会议方面回应。

深度见解

该说法提出了AI学术同行评审流程中的质量问题,但目前只有投稿作者单方陈述,尚未获得ICLR或审稿人确认。

Got my reviews yesterday, and honestly, I'm starting to question the credibility of the entire review process.

One of the reviewers seems to have submitted a review for a completely different paper. And I don't mean they misunderstood our method or missed the main contribution. Their entire paper summary describes a completely different research problem, method, and set of experiments. It has practically nothing to do with our submission, yet they went ahead and gave it a rejection.

Of the other two reviewers, one actually provided a good, thoughtful review, correctly identifying the strengths and weaknesses of our work. The other, however, didn't seem to have read the paper carefully. They criticized our negative findings as a weakness, despite the fact that investigating and demonstrating the limitations of existing approaches is explicitly part of the paper's objective.

I'm perfectly fine with criticism, rejection, or reviewers disagreeing with our conclusions. That's part of research. But how is an author supposed to respond when one reviewer is apparently reviewing an entirely different manuscript?

Has anyone experienced something like this before? Should I contact the AC directly, and is there any realistic chance of getting such a review disregarded or corrected?

I'm genuinely at a loss as to how something like this happens at a conference of this scale.

submitted by /u/rohitx0 [link] [comments]

#ICLR 2027

原文约 1 分钟读完阅读原文
群聊

还没有评论,来说说你的看法。