HN作者称LLM加剧伪装式个性化推销
一名Hacker News作者称,过去两年,其帖子和评论收到的邮件由以有用交流为主转为以噪声和推销为主。作者用Claude检查自2013年以来收到的邮件后,认为LLM让推销者更容易生成针对具体评论的逼真邮件,并以开放问题掩盖销售意图。为此,他开始先用简短邮件试探,收到非推销回复后再深入交流。
这一亲历案例展示了公开评论可能被用于定向销售,而伪装成真诚提问会加大收件人识别商业意图的难度。
I used to love getting emails from people in response to things I’ve written online, blog posts or Hacker News comments, but in the last 2 years it’s changed from mostly signal to mostly noise. I’ve met people in real life as a result of these emails, I’ve hired people based on these emails, and I’ve learned cool things through these emails but today it’s almost all pitches. I (had Claude) look through all the emails I’ve gotten about my posts and comments since 2013 to check my gut feeling:
LLMs have made this much easier, they can write convincing emails personalized to a real comment I wrote on HN. What’s worse is that they are often very deceptive. They don’t come out and say they are pitching you something, they ask a question, posing as if they care about the answer. Something like:
Hi Josh, saw your HN comment about [thing you said]. [Compliment.] I’m curious, [open-ended question]?
If someone took the time to email me asking a question I almost always respond to it but I’m having to rethink that policy. It’s like having an amplification attack pointed at you, someone sends 2-3 sentences (sometimes more) with an open-ended question then I turn around and write 2-3+ paragraphs to answer the question, only to get a response that is pitching a product/service. Here are a few real pivots I’ve received: