Five AI models show distinct app-building preferences in 80-app test
Reddit creator u/trez63 used the same one-paragraph prompt for three weeks to generate self-contained HTML apps from Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok and Muse, publishing 80 mostly unedited results. The creator observed that Claude favored mathematics and physics toys, ChatGPT produced calm productivity tools, Muse generated household utilities, Grok frequently used the “Forge” suffix, and Gemini favored CamelCase names; reported average file sizes ranged from 12 KB for Grok to 44 KB for ChatGPT. The experiment was a single creator’s self-reported community project, with some apps receiving extra post-generation prompting and some scheduled runs skipped because of credit limits or errors.
The side-by-side comparison offers a concrete, replicable view of how five AI models approach identical open-ended coding requests, while remaining observational rather than a controlled benchmark.
The scheduled prompt is the same every day: you’re in a coding contest, write one self-contained HTML file, no libraries, no network, you pick what to build, and it can’t repeat anything you’ve built before. No follow-ups, no fixes. Whatever comes back gets published but in a few cases I asked for some added vibe coding post generation.
Models: Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok, Muse. 80 apps so far. Things I didn’t expect:
Left alone, they each pick a lane.
- Claude builds math and physics toys: a wave tank, a spectrogram you draw on, an orrery, a Hilbert curve explorer.
- ChatGPT builds calm productivity tools with one-word names: Tradeoff, Stillpoint, Backplan, Draftloom.
- Muse builds household utilities: a budget, a pantry tracker, a meeting cost meter.
- Grok has named 5 of its 9 apps “something-Forge”: PulseForge, DealForge, CanvasForge, FlowForge, PipelineForge.
- Gemini does CamelCase compounds: ChromaWave, KanbanFlow, DocuForge, LoadMaster.
They size the job very differently. Same prompt, average file size: ChatGPT 44 KB, Claude 36 KB, Muse 21 KB, Gemini 17 KB, Grok 12 KB.
I did have it focus on productivity and business apps for a week but I then removed that restriction as it was getting very boring.