Three image-edit models tested on a knitted designer-toy prompt
AI summary
A Reddit user compared GPT Image 2.5 Sunburst, GPT Image 2.5 Flare and MAI-Image-2.6 on the same photo and prompt through the Atlas Cloud API. MAI-Image-2.6 was the only model to produce the requested oversized, broad head with tiny centered features, completing in 1 minute 1 second at a billed cost of $0.06. Sunburst and Flare produced similar knitted portraits with normal head proportions; Flare finished in 1 minute 4 seconds, versus 3 minutes 59 seconds for Sunburst, with both billed at $0.10.
In-depth insight
The preliminary comparison highlights a concrete instruction-following difference between the three image-edit models, while showing that Flare was substantially faster than Sunburst in this test.
| The photo to knitted designer toy prompt is everywhere this week, so I shortened it to one paragraph and ran it on the same photo, a laughing grandpa with a strawberry ice cream on a boardwalk, with three edit models. The line that makes this prompt work is "oversized, horizontally broad head with tiny features in the center". Both GPT Image 2.5 tiers ignored it and made a faithful knitted portrait, great yarn on the beard and every flamingo on the shirt, but the proportions of a normal person. MAI-Image-2.6 actually made the designer toy shape. Flare cost the same as Sunburst at high quality and was almost four times faster, so I see no reason to use Sunburst for this one. If you want the exaggerated toy shape, MAI is also the cheapest of the three, it just tops out at 1024 pixels. Ran all three through the Atlas Cloud API. Prompt in the comments. submitted by /u/Fun_Walk_4965 [link] [comments] |