SemiAnalysis says it was wrong about Gemini 4 and withdraws one word
SemiAnalysis posted an “apology form” on X addressed to Google DeepMind chairman Demis Hassabis, saying, “Demis, about Gemini 4, we were wrong,” and saying it wanted to withdraw one word. The outlet crossed out “is” from its earlier headline, “Gemini is cooked,” changing the phrase to “Gemini actually did something.” The report says this followed Google’s releases of Gemini 4 Argon, Carbon, Hydrogen and Neon, which received positive social-media reactions. It does not establish that SemiAnalysis retracted its broader analysis.
The post marks a public correction to SemiAnalysis’s earlier characterization of Gemini 4, while making clear that the change was limited to withdrawing one word. The report is a single-outlet account based primarily on social-media posts and does not establish a broader retraction.

今天,知名半导体和 AI 研究机构 SemiAnalysis 在 X 上发了一张写给 Google DeepMind 主席 Demis Hassabis 的《向 Google 道歉专用表》。

理由一栏勾了包括「我只看了 X 上大家的消息」、「我那在 Anthropic 工作的室友,说服我相信 Gemini 已经完了」和「我没有阅读模型卡」等原因。最有意思的是最后一行:「Demis,关于 Gemini 4,我们错了。我们只想撤回一个词。」
他们从自己当初的标题里划掉了一个 is:Gemini is cooked。一句「Gemini 完了」,变成了「Gemini 这回真做出了点东西」。
#SemiAnalysis#Google DeepMind#Gemini 4 Argon#Gemini 4 Carbon#Gemini 4 Hydrogen#Gemini 4 Neon#Demis Hassabis#Arthur Douillard