Reddit user compares three Claude Code UI-design skills
Reddit poster vinishkapoor ran three Claude Code UI-design skills—Anthropic's frontend-design, Impeccable, and Hallmark—once each on separate projects using the same brief for a fictional coffee delivery site called Brewline. The frontend-design run finished in 54 seconds with large typography and a tilted coffee-bag ticket; Impeccable produced a blue-and-amber layout but only its written guidance was tested; Hallmark produced the richest editorial-style page, though it had a spacing defect and no lint result because the run stopped at an approval prompt.
The comparison offers an anecdotal view of differences among Claude Code UI-design skills, including output style, one reported completion time, setup requirements, and defects, but each skill ran only once.
| Same prompt, three separate projects, one skill each: a one-page site for a made-up coffee delivery service called Brewline. frontend-design (Anthropic): Big type and a tilted coffee bag ticket instead of a stock photo, with clean plan rows. Done in 54 seconds. It said the prices were placeholders and that it hadn’t opened the page in a browser. Impeccable: A loud blue and amber page with a delivery route line across the hero. I didn’t run its launcher script (it downloads a program on first use), and Claude listed exactly which steps it skipped because of that. So this shows Impeccable’s written guidance, not its full tooling. Hallmark: The richest page: warm editorial serif with a real photo (linked from Wikimedia, so it needs a network connection). The plan rows had a spacing flaw where the price ran into the Choose link. I can’t report its lint result, because the run ended while it was waiting for approval. None of them looked like the others. Funny enough, two of them came up with the same blue and amber delivery-line idea. For most people I’d start with frontend-design. It’s one text file with nothing to install. Each skill ran once, so a second run could look different. And don’t stack all three in one project, because their rules conflict. Screenshots of all three pages: https://aiparabellum.com/best-claude-code-skills-ui-design/ submitted by /u/vinishkapoor [link] [comments] |