欧盟法院顾问提示Gemini版权风险
据TechRepublic和The Next Web报道,总法律顾问Maciej Szpunar表示,Gemini非法获取新闻文章或在回答中大量重现其具体表达时,可能侵犯出版商权利。他建议欧盟法院不予回答训练问题,因为案件缺乏Like Company文章用于训练Gemini的证据,并认为出版商提出的具体示例尚未证明侵权。该意见不具约束力,欧盟法院尚未作出最终判决。
该意见在法律上区分了模型训练与检索型输出,对AI出版商、检索增强生成系统和新闻出版商具有重要影响,但本身并未设立新的合规要求。
Google’s Gemini chatbot may infringe EU publishers’ rights when it retrieves and reuses news articles in certain circumstances, an adviser to the bloc’s highest court said on Nov. 3.
Advocate General Maciej Szpunar delivered the nonbinding opinion in a dispute between Hungarian publisher Like Company and Google Ireland. The Court of Justice of the European Union has not yet ruled.
For businesses building or buying AI tools that retrieve online content, the case raises questions about how those tools access source material and reproduce it in their answers.
According to thecourt’s explanation of the opinion, the case concerns both alleged training use and Gemini’s retrieval of articles to answer questions.
Szpunar proposed that infringement could arise from unlawful access, including bypassing effective technical protections, or from answers that recognizably reproduce an article’s expression so extensively that they substitute for reading it. Reporting the same facts alone would not meet that test.
He recommended that the court decline to answer the training questions because the case lacked evidence that Like Company’s articles had been used to train Gemini. His preliminary assessment also suggested that the publisher’s specific chatbot example did not establish infringement, subject to the Hungarian court’s findings.