EU court adviser weighs Gemini copyright risk
Advocate General Maciej Szpunar said Gemini may infringe publishers’ rights when it unlawfully retrieves news articles or substantially reproduces their expression in answers, according to TechRepublic and The Next Web. He recommended that the Court of Justice of the European Union not answer the training questions because the record lacks evidence that Like Company’s articles trained Gemini, while his preliminary view did not establish infringement in the publisher’s specific example. The opinion is nonbinding, and the court has not issued a final ruling.
The opinion draws a material legal distinction between model training and retrieval-based outputs for AI publishers, RAG systems, and press publishers, although it does not itself create a new compliance rule.
Google’s Gemini chatbot may infringe EU publishers’ rights when it retrieves and reuses news articles in certain circumstances, an adviser to the bloc’s highest court said on Nov. 3.
Advocate General Maciej Szpunar delivered the nonbinding opinion in a dispute between Hungarian publisher Like Company and Google Ireland. The Court of Justice of the European Union has not yet ruled.
For businesses building or buying AI tools that retrieve online content, the case raises questions about how those tools access source material and reproduce it in their answers.
According to thecourt’s explanation of the opinion, the case concerns both alleged training use and Gemini’s retrieval of articles to answer questions.
Szpunar proposed that infringement could arise from unlawful access, including bypassing effective technical protections, or from answers that recognizably reproduce an article’s expression so extensively that they substitute for reading it. Reporting the same facts alone would not meet that test.
He recommended that the court decline to answer the training questions because the case lacked evidence that Like Company’s articles had been used to train Gemini. His preliminary assessment also suggested that the publisher’s specific chatbot example did not establish infringement, subject to the Hungarian court’s findings.