Judge Rules Anthropic Used Illegally Obtained Books to Train Claude
In Bartz v. Anthropic, Judge William Alsup ruled that Anthropic unlawfully scraped and pirated the works of more than 10 Stanford professors to create a training library for Claude. The judge treated training on legally acquired books as fair use. A $1.5 billion settlement provided compensation to authors and publishers of nearly 500,000 registered works, but Tobias Wolff and 27 other authors said it was insufficient. Wolff and Chang-rae Lee opted out and are pursuing separate claims in Cruz v. Anthropic.
The decision establishes a reported current rule against using pirated books to create training libraries while treating legally acquired books as fair use for model training. The report says the legal future of mass scraping for AI models remains uncertain as authors pursue additional lawsuits and licensing initiatives.
AI giant Anthropic illegally scraped and pirated the work of over 10 Stanford professors to train its Claude models, a federal judge ruled in a May 2026 lawsuit.
Anthropic previously trained Claude on illegally obtained texts from professors Tobias Wolff, Abraham Verghese, Chang-Rae Lee, Daniel Mason, Hayagreeva Rao and Myra Strober. In Bartz v. Anthropic, which the Authors Alliance calls the largest copyright settlement involving an AI company, Judge William Alsup ruled that Anthropic could no longer pirate books to create a permanent central library.
While blocking the piracy of work to train AI, Alsup justified the legal acquisition of books to train Claude’s Large Language Models (LLMs) as fair use. He compared AI training to how humans can read, internalize and remember a book’s themes and style. “Like any reader aspiring to be a writer, Anthropic’s LLMs trained upon works not to race ahead and replicate or supplant them — but to turn a hard corner and create something different,” he wrote.
The $1.5 billion settlement went to authors and publishers of nearly 500,000 registered works. Wolff and 27 other authors say the settlement isn’t enough.
#Anthropic#Claude#Bartz v. Anthropic#Cruz v. Anthropic#Stanford University