Outlier and AI Data Work Face Labor-Practice Scrutiny
Rest of World reports that Scale AI's Outlier advertises up to $180 an hour for U.S. physicians designing cardiac scenarios and reviewing AI-generated reports, while similar work in the Philippines and Tanzania is advertised at much lower rates. Interviews with more than 30 workers describe a recurring pattern of rising demands, shorter target times, disappearing tasks and falling pay as projects progress. The report also says a proposed settlement involving Scale AI workers received preliminary approval in San Francisco, although the company denies wrongdoing.
The investigation documents how AI training and evaluation labor is organized and priced, giving current evidence for scrutiny of platform-controlled pay and working conditions.
The gig economy has arrived for cardiologists. Recruiting platform Outlier, run by Scale AI, advertises offers of up to $180 an hour for physicians in the U.S. to design complex cardiac scenarios, review artificial intelligence-generated reports, and rank model outputs. The site offers up to $7.50 an hour for Tagalog work in the Philippines for the same job, and up to $12.50 an hour for Swahili in Tanzania.
Companies like Scale AI first outsourced data work to wherever labor was cheapest. Now, they are recruiting physicians, lawyers, and Ph.D.s to generate and annotate data, rank model answers, and verify outputs. Higher credentials can raise the advertised rate, but the platform still controls payment and working conditions.
They begin by paying well to build a workforce, then they cut the rates and move on.
I’ve spent the last six years interviewing the people who do this work. Most were in Venezuela, where economic collapse has left a large, educated population online and out of options. One of them, Rogelio, taught computer science until the economic crisis and the pandemic left his family without work. His 13-year-old son discovered they could earn money labeling images of cars and roads on the platforms Hive and Scale AI’s Remotasks, using a laptop the Hugo Chávez government had issued to schoolchildren a decade earlier. The boy made 18 cents for a few hours of work. Rogelio joined him and made just over $2 on his first day.
#Outlier#Scale AI#Remotasks#Hive#Meta#Mercor#OpenAI#Anthropic#Partnership on AI#Fairwork#Majorel