《质量效应》作曲家谈AI创作边界
TechRadar报道,《质量效应》和《质量效应2》作曲家Jack Wall认为,只要创作者仍掌握创作决策,AI作为辅助工具是可以接受的。他反对AI音乐,认为其是在复制既有作品,并强调机器不是人,因此不能成为艺术家。《使命召唤》作曲家Jason Graves也表示,AI无法取代人类创作者的情感深度与灵感。
Wall与Graves明确表达了各自立场,为游戏开发与AI音乐领域关于AI辅助和替代人类创作的争议提供了可归属的观点。
- Original Mass Effect composer Jack Wall shares his stance on AI in video games
- Wall believes the tech shouldn't replace human creativity, and "as long as it’s a creative tool to get you going, it’s fine"
- He adds that "Machines can never be artists as they aren’t humans"
Mass Effectand Mass Effect 2 composer Jack Wall has shared his stance on AI music and the technology being used as a replacement in video games.
It's hard to ignore how rampant artificial intelligence has become in everyday life. It's become controversial and, as many continue to object to the tech, an unwelcome part of the entertainment business, dramatically changing the gaming landscape.
As AI becomes increasingly popular, some studios have been called out for their egregious use of AI, and tech companies like Nvidia have taken advantage of it to push AI-enhanced upscaling technology.
In an interview with TechRadar Gaming, the original Mass Effect composer shared his opinion on AI — something that wasn't around 20 years ago during the creation of BioWare's iconic sci-fi series — and believes the tech shouldn't replace human creativity, but only be a "creative tool" to help.
"I think as long as it’s a creative tool to get you going, it’s fine," Wall said. "I’m not a fan of AI music. AI music is just copying what’s been done before. But if you use it as a tool, and you’re still making the creative decisions, I think it’s fine."
The composer was firm on his stance that AI can never replace the work of real people, adding, "AI is not an artist."
"Machines can never be artists as they aren’t human," he said. "The entire purpose of art is to be a human form of communication. Full stop."
Elsewhere, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 composer Jason Graves also spoke out against AI in video games, saying, "Nothing will ever replace the emotional depth and creative inspiration of human beings as artists and creators."
"Music is not just a bunch of notes strung together," Graves told TechRadar Gaming.