Rich Hickey: 'AI' Is Not a Tool — LLMs Are Automation
Clojure creator Rich Hickey argues in a LinkedIn essay that calling LLMs "tools" is misleading: a tool is wielded by hand, predictable, deterministic and gives continuous feedback, whereas LLMs — by his account — lack control, intention and sensory feedback, and are better described as automation. He writes that using an LLM to read papers or write code hands the work to a capricious automaton, leaving the user to guess at prompts that a software update can render obsolete. He adds that tools do not get "misaligned," "go rogue" or "escape containment," so treating LLMs as merely tools obscures intrinsic differences.
The argument presses on a common industry metaphor: whether LLMs are framed as tools or automation shapes how people think about human-AI collaboration and responsibility.
The source text is unavailable here. Read the original for the full story.