Create

Sign in to ReadmeX

or

How we handle your data: Privacy Policy

ReadmeX

Your AI reading companion

What would you like to catch up on?

Pick a briefing, or ask your own question.

Your community and people briefings stay personal to you.

Story

Xiangya paper questioned over AI-image claims and data consistency

AI summary

A Chinese commentary raises concerns about a Second Xiangya Hospital paper on microplastics and nasopharyngeal carcinoma progression. The commentary cites text errors, unusually uniform cell images, a scale bar labeled with 12 millimeters per centimeter, and figures that appear to show declining cell viability as microplastic concentrations rise, contrary to the paper’s stated claim of increased activity. It suggests the scale bar may have been AI-generated but does not establish that generative AI produced or altered the paper. The supplied material contains no author or journal response.

In-depth insight

The reported figure discrepancy affects a key part of the paper’s evidence chain. The commentary also warns that AI-generated errors can be inserted into otherwise plausible material, increasing the work required to check scientific outputs.

最近我刷到一篇神奇的论文。这是湘雅二院团队关于微塑料促进鼻咽癌恶性进展的研究。正文第一页的第二个脚注里,作者把“湖南省”写成了“人类省”。如果是结尾参考文献、基金名称之类的写错也就算了,这可是开篇文字;而且上两行写了两次湖南了,下面有一行也写了湖南,偏偏这个位置错了。这就错得很神奇。还没完。邮编数字里的“1”......

本文来自微信公众号: 雷叔写故事 ,作者:小林

最近我刷到一篇神奇的论文。

这是湘雅二院团队关于微塑料促进鼻咽癌恶性进展的研究。

正文第一页的第二个脚注里,作者把“湖南省”写成了“人类省”。

#Second Xiangya Hospital#Central South University

Original · 6 min readRead the original
Group chat

No comments yet. Start the conversation.