Create

Sign in to ReadmeX

or

How we handle your data: Privacy Policy

ReadmeX

Your AI reading companion

What would you like to catch up on?

Pick a briefing, or ask your own question.

Your community and people briefings stay personal to you.

Story

Lean Checks Fall Short for AI-Generated Mathematics

AI summary

Tiger Sniff AI, citing a preprint by Anders Hansen, Fabian Circelli and Alexander Bastounis, reports that part of OpenAI's Navier–Stokes paper differs from the proposition verified by its Lean code. The report also describes Lean 4 kernel vulnerabilities that reportedly allowed false proofs to pass until the Lean team patched them in version 4.33.1.

In-depth insight

Passing Lean validation guarantees only that the encoded proposition follows under the checked assumptions; it does not by itself establish that an AI preserved a paper's intended conditions or that the proof-assistant is free of implementation flaws.

今年9月,Anthropic宣布,AI用11天把费马大定理的证明写成1300万行Lean代码。几天后,OpenAI又宣称用AI解决了纳维–斯托克斯难题。两项成果都附有通过Lean检查的代码。但数学家随后发现,OpenAI文字论文中的部分中间结论,与Lean代码实际验证的内容并不一致。Lean被视为数学的“机器......

本文来自微信公众号: 返朴 ,作者:任平生

今年9月,Anthropic宣布,AI用11天把费马大定理的证明写成1300万行Lean代码。几天后,OpenAI又宣称用AI解决了纳维–斯托克斯难题。两项成果都附有通过Lean检查的代码。但数学家随后发现,OpenAI文字论文中的部分中间结论,与Lean代码实际验证的内容并不一致。

#Anthropic#OpenAI#Claude#Lean#Lean 4.33.1#Mathlib#ChatGPT

Original · 15 min readRead the original
Group chat

No comments yet. Start the conversation.