Reddit 用户因记忆不足放弃用 Claude 当助手
Reddit 用户 u/brisadanet 表示,经过数月尝试后,他放弃将 Claude 用作个人助手,原因是其跨对话和项目保留记忆与上下文的能力不足。他仍认可 Claude 的创作和整理能力,但称维护工作流需要反复手工调整,甚至让用户变成“助手的助手”;相比之下,他在 ChatGPT 上的个人助手设置首次回应更符合预期。
这则详尽的用户经历显示,出色的创作能力未必能弥补长期个人工作流中的记忆、上下文和主动协助不足。
imma keep it simple: i switched from chatgpt to Claude once i learnt about its ability to edit video, create artifacts, run your work like a team, create hacks/organize your work. I already knew about its writing qualities, but the personalization and context ChatGPT had of me made it hard to switch. i switched: in the beggining, I was amazed with its ability to create new things (and still am). however, i really wanted to use it as my personal assistant and i’m done trying. it drives me completely nuts its lack of memory/context through chats and even within projects and its inability to think ahead of me.
more context: after some weeks of use, i created a project on Claude for this purpose. i know Claude projects start almost from zero, so I spent some time creating that context, memory, instructions, rules, preferences, etc. then, i spent months building a structure and perfecting the system. i studied how Claude works. i know how long conversations seem to become less efficient with time and extension. how it compacts its memories. how projects’ memories do not communicate with its general memory and vice-versa. how threads rely on the coordinator and have little context to be more efficient. i reviewed .md files and perfected them. gave it all the updated context both Claude and ChatGPT had about me/my preferences. edited project instructions. wrote descriptions on each project or general settings. deleted duplicates and reviewed everything it knew, frequently. reviewed my rules and kept them nice and short, although it was a complex matter (different topics and tasks of my life require different actions). gave feedback. asked what went wrong this time, what failed. edited rules again. reminded the purpose of the project. deleted old docs and threads.