Pangram dispute over David Silva Rojas’s award-winning novel
The Decoder reports that AI-detection tool Pangram classified 99 percent of David Silva Rojas’s novel “Donde el agua trabaja” as AI-generated. Mexican publisher Almadía reviewed the author’s documents and continues to support her and the award, while Silva Rojas says critics dismissed the allegations as racist without addressing Pangram’s results. The Authors Guild warns against using AI detectors as the sole basis for decisions, and Gallimard reportedly plans to screen manuscripts with Pangram starting next year.
The dispute highlights the risk of using AI detection results as a single criterion in literary judgments, even as a major publisher weighs broader manuscript screening.
Pangram flags 99 percent of an award-winning Peruvian novel as AI-generated, but the publisher stands by its author
Nov 18, 2026
AI detection tool Pangram flags 99 percent of the award-winning novel "Donde el agua trabaja" by Peruvian author David Silva Rojas as AI-generated. Despite these allegations, Mexican publisher Almadía is standing by the award after reviewing documents from the author, according to an essay in The Point Magazine. According to the newspaper El País, Pangram had also attributed more than 80 percent of text from interviews, an essay, and the author's Instagram denial to AI.
In her essay, the author accuses Latin American critics of ignoring Pangram's test results and dismissing the allegations wholesale as racist. She compares the debate to the confirmed use of AI by Thélyson Orélien, as well as accusations involving the Caine Prize and Jamir Nazir, who kept his award. She also argues that literary juries often favor clichéd stories about minorities, which language models can easily imitate. Publisher Gallimard reportedly plans to screen manuscripts with Pangram starting next year.
#Pangram#Donde el agua trabaja#David Silva Rojas#Almadía#Authors Guild#Gallimard