Create

Sign in to ReadmeX

or

How we handle your data: Privacy Policy

ReadmeX

Your AI reading companion

What would you like to catch up on?

Pick a briefing, or ask your own question.

Your community and people briefings stay personal to you.

Story

Reddit User Reports OpenAI Dot Losing Workflow Consistency

AI summary

In a letter posted to r/OpenAI, Reddit user /u/Danny7Guns said OpenAI Dot initially followed instructions and project SOPs well, but required more oversight after about a week. The user later reported that Dot forgot or contradicted SOPs even after reminders, while a suggested reboot provided only temporary improvement. The author also said the behavior consumed additional time and usage resources, though these costs were personal and unverified.

In-depth insight

The account highlights a user-level concern about whether AI coding assistants can retain and consistently apply workflow rules over time, but one anecdote does not establish a broader product failure.

Dear OpenAI,

You had a great idea with Dot. After release, for a week or so, it was fantastic. It was a great assistant that followed instructions well and could stick to project SOPs. It only took a week or so, however, and Dot began requiring more and more oversight. It wasn't long before I was working more on getting Dot to consistently follow workflow rules than I was working on my project itself. Tibo made indemnification attempts with a many resets. I was content with this because at least I wasn't paying money for the time and usage lost due to the errors of Dot. But there is no recourse for the time, added server costs due to the now extended development schedule, delay to market opportunity costs, etc. Another week into use, I discovered Dot not just failing to remember SOPs but acting against them after reminders. Using a reddit poster's suggestion to reboot, I did, and that helped.

But it seemed as though Dot's memory became more and more short term each day. To mitigate this, I updated agents.md and config.toml files for Codex and my CLI. But, there were no such files for Dot to keep that agent in line. I added plugins and skills. I installed second memory software like mempalace and code mapping software like Enola. Then I discovered that scheduled tasks can monitor events. So, I built scheduled tasks to give dot instructions that followed my SOPs. It seems odd to me that I would have to build so many supports and checkpoints for my DOT when it was advertised to learn how I work and improve with time. My experience has been quite opposite. My Dot has refused to learn how I work and has gotten worse with time. It has wasted my time and usage resources since its release which, consequently has increased my monetary cost, time costs and opportunity costs for not getting my product to market.

#OpenAI#Dot#Codex#Claude Duet#Anthropic

Original · 2 min readRead the original
Group chat

No comments yet. Start the conversation.